Insights

How to Choose a Multifamily Broker in the Bay Area

Most apartment owners sell a building once or twice in a lifetime, and the broker they pick can move the price by more than the commission costs. Big sales totals are easy to find on every broker’s website. These eight questions tell you more.

1. How Many Sales Have You Closed in My City in the Last Two Years?

Region-wide totals hide where a team actually works. Ask for recent sales within a few miles of your building, with unit counts and price per unit. Local comps drive your price, and a broker who closed them knows the buyers who paid.

2. Who Will Work on My Sale Day to Day?

On large teams, the names on the website win the listing and junior agents run it. Ask who will underwrite, show the building and negotiate, and how often you will hear from a senior partner.

3. How Will You Value My Building, and Is Land Value Part of It?

A good valuation shows its work: income, expenses, cap rate and comparable sales. In transit areas affected by SB 79, it should also show what a developer would pay for the site. If a broker cannot answer that, you may be pricing the wrong buyer.

4. Who Are the Likely Buyers, by Name or Type?

You want to hear specifics: local private investors, 1031 exchangers with deadlines, family offices, developers. A broker who says “our database” without naming a buyer type is guessing.

5. How Do You Run the Offer Process?

Ask how they create competition: call-for-offers dates, buyer qualification, best-and-final rounds. Also ask how often their listings sell to buyers they represent on both sides, and how that is disclosed.

6. How Do You Handle Rent Control and Tenant Issues?

The Peninsula and South Bay have different rules city by city. Your broker should explain how local rules affect your price and what buyers’ lenders will ask for.

7. If I’m Exchanging, How Will You Protect My 1031 Timeline?

The 45-day identification and 180-day closing deadlines are strict. Ask how the broker lines up replacement options before you list, and whether they push you toward their own inventory.

8. What Will You Do If the First Offers Come in Low?

Every listing hits resistance. Ask for a real example of how they repositioned a property, adjusted marketing or found a different buyer pool.

How Thomson Danforth Answers These Questions

We work two counties, San Mateo and Santa Clara, and can show you recent sales near your building. Senior partners stay on every transaction. Every valuation includes an income view and a development view, built on institutional underwriting experience. And we plan your 1031 exchange before your building goes to market.

Free download

The Owner’s Broker Interview Checklist

All eight questions on one printable page, with what to listen for, red flags, and a scorecard to compare up to three brokers side by side.

    Interview Us. Request a Valuation and Ask Us All Eight.